Abstract
Introduction
The dramatic rise of e-cigarette use has raised significant environmental concerns, largely due to unclear disposal guidance from manufacturers and regulatory agencies. This review aimed to synthesize existing research on the environmental impacts of post-consumer e-cigarette waste and disposal.
Methods
We conducted a comprehensive search of the databases Medline, Embase, Web of Science, and Google Scholar on the environmental impacts of e-cigarette waste from market inception in 2004 to June 2024. Following abstract and title screening, full-text review, and extraction by two authors, 18 papers were identified for inclusion in the study.
Results
Thematic analysis revealed the following results: 1) The chemical, metallic, and electrical composition of e-cigarettes qualify these devices as hazardous and electronic waste products; 2) E-liquid, along with its chemical and flavoring constituents, negatively impact aquatic and terrestrial organisms; 3) Although less harmful to the environment than tobacco cigarettes, e-cigarettes still pose environmental risks, particularly those that are disposable or contain disposable components (i.e., pods/cartridges); 4) Consumer disposal practices are often unsafe and ineffective.
Conclusions
In jurisdictions where e-cigarettes are legally sold, we recommend that regulatory agencies establish clear, enforceable guidelines for e-cigarette disposal and recycling. This should include well-defined manufacturer responsibility frameworks, including displaying recycling information on their products and assuming responsibility for recycling costs. Public education campaigns are also needed to raise awareness of e-cigarette waste issues. Further research into the environmental impact of e-cigarette waste and innovative recycling systems is crucial to better understand and address this emerging issue.
Implications
Previous reviews on e-cigarette waste and disposal have primarily called attention to gaps in research, offering limited insight into the full scope of its environmental harm. This review offers the most thorough synthesis to date, detailing how e-cigarettes pose risks to ecosystems due to their chemical, metallic, and electrical components. Findings from this review underscore the need for urgent regulatory guidelines on disposal and recycling, enhanced public awareness, and manufacturer accountability to mitigate the environmental impact of post-consumer e-cigarette waste.
